I’m on BookLikes!

The power of names: why saying someone's true name matters

In Middle-earth, a name is rarely a label. Gandalf is Gandalf the Grey long before he is Gandalf the White, and asking him who he is produces a riddle rather than an answer. Tom Bombadil, when the hobbits demand a name, replies with song. The Rangers of the North take a title, give it up, take it back. And the Ring, when it takes Isildur, does not merely kill him: it strikes his name out of the Records and leaves a grey blur riding a black shape. Keep hold of your true name in Tolkien's world and you remain a person; lose it and you become weather.

That machinery has a long afterlife. Australians have a famously relaxed habit with names — shortening them, trading them, bestowing nicknames so casually that the name on the birth certificate can go unread for decades — and they argue loudly in public about names attached to national days, sportspeople and suburbs. Tolkien's questions about naming therefore land somewhere crowded rather than somewhere quaint. I have followed this thread across essays, reading lists and interviews, and the same point keeps surfacing: in the stories we return to, the name is where the power sits, and saying it is an act with consequences.

A name in Middle-earth is a tether to the world

Say what a name does in Tolkien's world and the answer comes quickly: it keeps a thing inside the world. When a person is swallowed by the Ring, the taking is not purely physical. Isildur's name is struck from the Records of the Second Age, and the man dissolves into the shape that carries the Ring away from Mount Doom. The Nazgûl were once kings with names cut on their tombs, and they are wraiths in which nothing readable survives.

This is why the Ring's inscription matters more than its poetry. Written in Black Speech, the letters running around the band paraphrase the names of those it has swallowed, rendered as gibberish so the bearer becomes unintelligible. The Ring keeps a list, and it keeps it illegible. To undo the Ring, someone has to speak the original words in the original tongue, which makes the destruction of the One Ring a philological problem before it is ever a martial one.

Elendil named the Three Rings for his sons — Vilya, Marillia and Anguirel — tying the objects to inheritance, grief and continuity. Gil-galad gave Nenya to Galadriel as the ring of preservation, while Círdan's ring carries no name at all, an absence many readers take as a mark of its character. Even the land gets renamed when history turns: after the drowning, the true name Númenor, the West of the Setting Sun, gives way to Middle-earth, so the Third Age is remembered under a different name from the Second.

Names that arrive with a history attached

Tolkien's interest in names was philological before it was magical. In his essay on the Sirens of the Lord of the Rings, and in the pages of the Appendices, he plays the etymologist: the name of a thing usually predates the people who use it, and every name carries a fossil record of the world that made it.

The Dúnedain offer the clearest case. In Númenor, women took a new name on marriage, so that a name was an event rather than a label, and when the island sank, the survivors took Grey for themselves, becoming the Company of the Grey. The Gondor line runs on names with weight attached: Minas Ithil, the Tower of the Moon, was named by Minardor in memory of his daughter, and kings of the North carried names like the Ring of Barahir, which had passed from Tar-Minastir down to Elendil and finally to Isildur, the last possessor before the disaster.

Names of this sort do double duty. They locate a person in a family and a family in a history, and they can mislead as easily as they inform. A ruin keeps the name of the builders long after the builders are gone; a river keeps the name of the ford that gave way. Lúthien Tinuviel is older than Beren, and the whole of their story turns on a woman whose name existed before her lover ever heard it.

Saying a name out loud

Naming is one thing; speaking is another, and Tolkien treats the spoken name as a form of action. The clearest case is Beren. Taken in Sauron's jaws in the disguise of a cat, Beren speaks the name of Lúthien, and the Dark Lord's grip fails him. The name works because it holds a claim stronger than the power arrayed against it.

The same logic governs the Ring. Its destruction depends on a sentence spoken in Black Speech, the tongue of its makers, in which the names of the things the Ring commands are set down. Gandalf's fire cannot melt it, strength cannot break it, and no amount of clever sword-work will help. Only someone who can say the words as they were first said can unmake it.

Elsewhere the spoken name becomes a test of character. Gandalf asks his companions who they are in the darkness of the Barrow of the King, and the hobbits stumble. Tom Bombadil answers the same kind of question with a song about himself, and the song is the truest thing anyone learns about him. The Grey Company swears oaths aloud, a bound of service made of words, and the Rangers speak names of office as though the words carried the authority themselves.

Australian writers who inherited the idea

Tolkien's influence on fantasy is usually discussed in terms of invented languages and long genealogies, but the naming logic reached writers in this country with particular force. Trudi Canavan, who trained in theatre at the University of Melbourne and has worked as a writer in Sydney, builds her Magicians' Guild books around exactly this engine: the Guild holds knowledge of true names, and a magician who knows an enemy's true name has a weapon nothing else can supply. The books are contemporary and Australian in setting, yet the victory condition is medieval and spoken aloud.

Garth Nix, who has lived and worked in Sydney for decades, treats naming in the Old Kingdom as a craft with its own practitioners, where the correct word for a thing changes what the thing will do. The magic in those novels runs through the words themselves, and readers who grew up on Middle-earth recognise the family resemblance instantly.

Further back, Ursula Le Guin's Earthsea made a wizard's true name a burden as well as a key, a leash the naming of a person places on the namer's power. She was open about the debt. In Australia, the fandom's scholarly wing runs at the same time: Tolkien Down Under has gathered readers in Melbourne for decades, and Signum, the journal of the Tolkien Society of Australia, has published close reading out of Canberra for long enough to be a serious reference.

Names as they sound and behave in Australia

Ask an Australian what a name is worth and you will get a shrug and an example. Lachie for Lachlan, Bazza for a man named Barry, Shazza for Sharon, Muz for Murray. The nickname arrives early, sticks, and frequently outlasts the paperwork. A person's given name survives in the family, the birth certificate and a handful of old photographs, while the name in daily use is something invented at the school gate and never formally approved. It is a working culture of renaming, and it makes Tolkien's distinction between the name you are given and the name that holds you unusually easy to feel.

The public argument runs alongside it. In December 2023 the Australian Parliament voted to describe 26 January as January 26 Day, a renaming driven by a dispute about what the old name concealed. That is the argument about names in its rawest form: whether a name is a description or an apology, and who gets to decide which.

Melbourne offers a third register. Public signs across the city acknowledge the Wurundjeri Woi-wurrung peoples of the Kulin Nation as the Traditional Owners of the land, and the Country names carried by those languages do not describe a single feature so much as a web of relations. Naming Country is not labelling it. Meanwhile the bookshops carry their own particular version of the story: Dymocks and Angus & Robertson, where the hardbacks of The Silmarillion arrive with the welcome of a returned favourite. Australian readers who prefer their books written at home can find them reviewed at First Page Panda, where the emphasis is on local writing rather than imported.

Speaking a name with care

The ethics of naming arrive fastest in Australia through the argument over deadnaming, the practice of using the name a person has publicly renounced. The case of Adam Goodes, and the years of commentary that followed, forced the country to argue about what a broadcaster owes a public figure who has asked to be called something else. The question is not pedantry. A name in daily use is how a community addresses someone, and insisting on the old one can withdraw recognition from the person who has claimed a new one.

For readers, the same attention applies to the books. Names are how a story is remembered and how a reader navigates it: the question asked at parties and in reading groups, who is that again, is really a question about whether a name has been given the attention it deserves. The reading communities on BookLikes are full of readers who will correct a misremembered name in a review, and the correction is rarely pedantic. It is the sign that the world was taken seriously.

The essays where I work through this thread sit at https://annemariegazzolo.com/, alongside reading lists, interviews and the notes I keep on how Australian readers handle the names they are given. Somewhere in the Shire or on the banks of the Anduin, a name is never just a handle for a person. It is the agreement by which the world recognises them, and in a culture as casual with names as Australia, that agreement is worth saying out loud.