The orc problem: born evil or made evil?
Tolkien’s orcs raise an uncomfortable question: are they evil by nature, or have they been made that way? The distinction matters beyond fantasy. If wickedness is fixed inheritance, appearance becomes an excuse for cruelty. If it is acquired, responsibility becomes complicated but does not vanish. Tolkien’s orcs move between those poles, changing from grotesque combatants in The Hobbit into workers, soldiers, propagandists and subjects of an industrial state in The Lord of the Rings. Their history suggests that cruelty can be cultivated until it seems natural, while remaining a series of choices rather than biological destiny.
That sits inside a moral universe in which created things do not begin evil simply because their makers desire them. Sauron, once one of the Maiar, serves Morgoth through pride and desire to rule. The orcs belong to a pattern of corruption rather than to a category outside reason. Yet “made evil” is not a synonym for “innocent”. Orcs deceive, bully, covet and kill, and many flourish where cruelty is rewarded. A damaged being can still act wrongly. The useful question is not whether influence or choice matters more, but how each shapes the other.
Australians meet inherited blame in public life as well as in stories. On a crowded tram in Melbourne, or over a flat white before work, people argue about immigration, race and identity without a simple line between prejudice and accountability. Literature cannot be ruled by statute, but public language offers a warning: reducing people to a group marked intrinsically bad can reproduce exclusion in ordinary conversation. Tolkien’s monsters make that warning visible without pretending that a fantasy race can settle a political argument.
From corrupted men to Sauron’s factory
Tolkien’s writing history complicates any answer. The published Hobbit presents goblin-like creatures whose kinship with humans is unexplained. In several early drafts of The Lord of the Rings, however, Tolkien explored the possibility that orcs were corrupted human captives. Later versions and the wider legendarium describe a distinct race-like population, associated first with Morgoth’s corruption and later remade, multiplied and organised by Sauron. Tolkien never supplied a final biology for them, and the gaps have invited sharply different readings. That incompleteness matters: it preserves uncertainty about what an orc is without erasing what an orc does.
The direction of change carries meaning too. Human corruption would make orcish cruelty resemble a fall from a better condition, with memory and kinship potentially surviving beneath the change. A separate creation makes their alienation more absolute. Their bodies, society and reproductive cycle can then become carriers of an identity that seems prior to individual choice. Tolkien’s invented biology avoids real-world racial taxonomy, yet it asks a disturbing hypothetical: what if the outward marks of otherness were built into the very form a corrupted people took?
Neither route is a neat answer. The early human idea can tempt readers to excuse orcish conduct as the result of enslavement; the later race can tempt them to treat cruelty as fixed essence. Tolkien’s more durable achievement is to keep those temptations in tension. The orc is shaped by Morgoth and Sauron, enters an inheritance of contempt, and is processed by a society that gives cruelty status. That is how being made becomes more than an excuse. It becomes a history.
The will inside the armour
Look closely at individual orcs and the question becomes harder to answer with slogans. Snaga, an orc in The Hobbit, disobeys, steals credit and hopes to avoid punishment. Shagrat and Gorbag, who survive their master’s death in The Hobbit, become suspicious rivals. In The Lord of the Rings, quarrels among Mordor’s servants reveal pride, fear and opportunism even when the larger war gives them a common enemy. Tolkien gives these beings language, ambition, tactical intelligence and dissension. None makes them friendly. Their actions cannot be read as the movements of a single monster with many hands.
This individuation fits Tolkien’s theological setting. Eru Ilúvatar does not create creatures as ready-made villains, and free will means created beings can turn towards corruption. An orc may be made in a hostile form, raised amid violence and taught to see weakness as opportunity, yet still choose how to respond. Tolkien’s moral distinction is not simply obedience versus rebellion. It concerns the direction of a will: domination, cruelty and contempt on one side; mercy, self-restraint and fellowship on the other.
Still, capacity for choice should not become a magician’s trick that makes every victim responsible for every harm done to them. Tolkien’s orcs can be cruel because they choose cruelty, but their choices are enabled and rewarded by a culture. Sauron does not need magical mind control to produce obedience; he needs armoury, hierarchy, fear and enough material comfort that compliance becomes easier than resistance. Being made therefore identifies the forces shaping conduct, while moral agency keeps those forces from becoming an alibi. The two ideas belong together, which is why simple acquittal or condemnation fails.
The machinery of hatred
Mordor is where this tension becomes concrete. Its furnaces, forges, mines, armouries and slave-driven workforces resemble the industrial war economy Tolkien feared. The orcs are not merely besieging soldiers; many keep the system running. Sauron’s power lies in machinery as well as magic, and his followers gain advancement by efficiency, ruthlessness and political usefulness. Tolkien saw industrialisation as a force capable of making war more efficient and more abstract. In his imagined factories, violence is translated into output, prisoners into labour and fear into productivity.
That translation has a recognisable Australian echo, without turning supermarkets into miniature Mordors. Consider a household in Perth placing a click-and-collect order through Coles: the customer sees a tidy list and a car park, while stock moves through warehouses, delivery contracts and algorithms. The service rests on a network whose workers and conditions disappear from the final exchange. Tolkien’s orcish economy makes the hidden chain visible by giving cruelty a face and a place in the process. The parallel is not moral equivalence. It is a reminder that convenience can conceal systems of pressure.
Mordor works because many of its inhabitants want it to work. Status, plunder and protection encourage cruelty; the rhetoric of the Eye gives private violence a public purpose. This matters because societies rarely become monstrous through one lurid event. Ordinary routines normalise small abuses, then larger ones, until the alternative starts to look subversive. Tolkien does not suggest that everyone beneath a bad ruler is equally culpable. He does suggest that a culture can educate desire. That warning feels urgent when institutions sell cruelty as efficiency or loyalty as obedience. The line from factory floor to battlefield is shorter than we like to admit.
Racialisation, otherness and Australian law
Orcs also invite comparison with the racialisation of other peoples, though simple allegory is hazardous. They are physically marked, segregated, labelled as lesser and used as an enemy whose defeat is presented as a civil good. Those features resemble mechanisms of empire. Tolkien’s South African childhood, service in the First World War and rejection of Nazi racial politics matter to his context, but they do not settle every moral question in his fiction. Some critics have warned that orc imagery can resemble antisemitic propaganda. Responsible reading acknowledges both the story’s warnings about scapegoating and the ease with which its images can be appropriated.
Australian law offers one way to test the distinction without pretending that Middle-earth is a jurisdiction. Canberra is home to the Commonwealth Parliament, which enacted the Racial Discrimination Act 1991; Victoria’s Racial Vilification and Hatred Act 1975 operates at state level, alongside laws elsewhere. That variation reflects Australia’s federal structure and the way judgements about prejudice move between national and local responsibility. The statutes do not tell us how to classify goblins. They show why group contempt deserves scrutiny wherever it appears.
The same scrutiny applies to publishers and readers in the Australian book market. Fantasy has a loyal local audience, visible on the shelves of Dymocks, in independent high-street bookshops and at annual events such as Supanova in Brisbane. Australian editions, reviews and classroom discussions determine which ideas about “other” groups children encounter. Tolkien’s work has unusual cultural durability: it is read as a classic, a school text and a template for later fantasy, including its monsters. A market need not intend prejudice for prejudice to travel. Images of monstrous races can be sold, praised and repeated long after their context has faded. Critical attention is part of responsible publishing and teaching, not a rejection of the stories.
A moral answer without a happy ending
The answer refuses a single category. Tolkien presents the orcs as made in a corrupted form, situated in a history of domination, and free to choose cruelty rather than goodness. Calling them innately evil erases that history and lets “they were always like this” perform the work of old racial stereotypes. Calling them merely victimised erases their agency, flattens differences among them and mistakes coercion for moral innocence. The more exact account is harsher and more hopeful at once. Their environment helps explain their conduct; it cannot excuse every act.
Hope enters through the collapse of the system that sustains them. Once Sauron’s power fails, the orcish armies fragment, flee or disappear, and later ages do not simply restore the old order. Tolkien does not stage a conversion campaign in which defeated creatures are patiently remade. Instead, his attention shifts to what can survive after an oppressive order: choice, stewardship and relationships that do not require domination. This is not a promise that societies are easily repaired. It is a narrative refusal to treat the habits of a corrupted world as permanent.
That refusal is why orcs remain more than a puzzle about fictional biology. They reveal how cruelty is taught, rewarded and copied, and how easily a person can mistake a made habit for fixed nature. For further essays on Tolkien, Middle-earth and the literary afterlife of his work, Anne Marie Gazzolo has gathered thoughtful literary reflections. The deepest challenge is not to decide that monsters are secretly noble. It is to see how ordinary people can be formed into cruel ones while retaining the capacity to answer for what they do.