The hunt for Gollum: A lesson in incomplete justice
The familiar hunt for Gollum begins with signs rather than a suspect: torn cloth, muddy prints, a bitter bargain and the story of a hobbit who slips away from his companions. In Tolkien’s telling, those clues invite confidence. By the time Frodo, Samwise Gamgee, Gandalf and Aragorn close in, however, the trail has become a story about possession, prejudice and the impossibility of securing a plain verdict. The title The Hunt for Gollum catches this movement from pursuit to moral uncertainty.
A screen adaptation can sharpen that uncertainty by making the hunted figure visible rather than leaving him at the edge of the hobbits’ tale. It can also flatten him into a chase. The difference matters. Gollum is both cause and casualty: Sméagol’s long history of loss explains his degradation without excusing what he does to Frodo. The hunt therefore offers a lesson in incomplete justice, one in which evidence, identity and responsibility refuse to fit inside a single category.
Evidence before explanation
The hunt operates first as a practical problem. Riders cross country, companions compare reports, and Samwise refuses to abandon a trail that others dismiss as hopeless. These actions belong to the clean grammar of adventure: identify a danger, follow its signs, corner the enemy. Yet the signs point backward as well as forward. Gollum’s trail is the trail of someone who has been excluded, deceived and steadily robbed of a stable self.
The public account therefore risks becoming partial. Call him thief, guide, monster, and the hunt appears intelligible; each label settles the meaning of his actions. Call him Sméagol and the narrative becomes less comfortable. His divided identity suggests a person capable of cruelty and care, greed and longing. This is where an adaptation faces a consequential choice: whether to preserve the old trail or stand close to the figure whose voice disturbs the certainty of that trail.
Viewpoint does more than change sympathy. It changes what counts as cause. A hand reaching for the One Ring can be read as an act of theft or as the final movement of a compulsion already present. The distinction cannot be settled by adding a flashback or enlarging a backstory. A viewer must decide whether earlier suffering explains the present action, diminishes it, or leaves it precisely as culpable while making its cost visible.
The fractured witness
Gollum is also his own unreliable witness. In The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, he lies, conceals and reshapes his past, yet fragments of truth break through his words. The famous “What business have you with me?” sounds defensive, but it also asks a fair question: why should these travellers treat his hunger and fear as nothing? The line gives the hunted body a voice before it can be made into an object of pursuit.
The Ring intensifies this fracture. Its promise of mastery answers the smallness Gollum experiences everywhere else, while its physical effects translate shame into appetite. The description of his wasted body makes history bodily: loss travels as hunger, and possession travels as the inability to recognise another person. Tolkien does not make these conditions invisible. They explain the ease with which cruelty can become habit.
Explanation is not exoneration. Gollum still informs the betrayers, exploits Frodo and tries to seize the Ring at the end. Responsibility remains, but it is layered rather than flat. A just reading must hold two propositions together: the Ring has narrowed his choices, and he continues to make choices that wound. Deny the first and become rigid; ignore the second and become sentimental.
Memory against the public record
Tolkien’s narrative form reinforces this difficulty. The published book presents itself as a recovered record, a great tale assembled from surviving fragments, annals and private testimony. Even within that frame, accounts differ in scope and certainty. Frodo’s endurance, Samwise’s loyalty and Gandalf’s long knowledge do not provide an exhaustive account of the Ring. The gaps are not merely historical. They are ethical spaces where judgement could otherwise become too easy.
Three recurring comparisons make the problem visible:
| Basis of judgement |
The public reading |
Gollum’s fractured perspective |
The tension created |
| Identity |
Thief, guide, monster |
Deprived child, corrupted seeker |
Labels conceal change |
| Evidence |
Tracks, riddles and reports |
Memory, shame and divided loyalty |
Certainty depends on incomplete testimony |
| Motive |
Recovery of the One Ring |
Fear, addiction and intermittent lucidity |
Coercion and agency overlap |
| Outcome |
Capture and punishment |
Continued dehumanisation |
Victory without restoration |
| Mercy |
Rarely enters the calculation |
Requires recognition of suffering |
Vengeance resists understanding |
None of these contrasts cancels the other. The Ring does exert real power, but so do habits, choices and the decisions of those who hunt. Likewise, pity cannot repair betrayal, just as punishment cannot restore a lost hand or an earlier self. Incomplete justice means admitting that a full account may produce uncertainty rather than a neat verdict. The reader has to hold responsibility without reducing Gollum to guilt.
Law, market and Australian judgement
Legal systems sharpen, rather than settle, questions of judgement. In Australia, a new film reaches audiences through the National Classification Scheme, with decisions made by the relevant state and territory authorities, while copyright in an adaptation falls within federal law. These institutions classify, permit and protect; they do not deliver a moral verdict on a fictional character. The contrast with Middle-earth is instructive. Sauron’s regime demands total obedience, whereas the company’s compassion is untidy, debatable and built through individual choices.
The Australian book market offers another everyday lens. At a Sydney second-hand bookshop, a battered copy may carry less market value than a newer edition, even when its annotations make it the better reading. Independent booksellers and online sellers serve different needs: one buyer wants a clean copy, another wants the translation with the old cover or a note pencilled by a previous owner. The Australian Consumer Law also requires sellers not to mislead customers about an item’s condition. Judgement by cover or cost is not the same as knowing what a book contains.
Daily habits in Australia make the same point from another direction. A passenger on a crowded Melbourne tram may catch only a few lines of an ebook before changing seats; a member of a suburban book club may hear one disputed passage discussed for an hour. Neither gets the whole story. Each forms a judgement from partial access. The parallel with Middle-earth is not that Australians are secretly like hobbits, but that ordinary conditions of attention resemble the fragments every reader brings to a difficult tale.
What the screen can add
A screen adaptation can make this ethical structure visible. The title The Hunt for Gollum places pursuit in front of us, but the camera may also linger on a face calculating survival, a hand hiding an object, or a body denied the comfort of an ordinary name. Such images can unsettle the heroic frame by showing that the hunt is also an occupation of territory and identity. They can resist the fantasy of a villain whose evil needs no history.
They can also slide towards a familiar danger: making the persecuted figure fascinating enough to excuse his violence. Empathy is not acquittal. The One Ring’s power and the cruelties of Mordor may explain Gollum’s course, yet neither removes the significance of his choices or the harm they cause to Frodo and Samwise. A responsible adaptation need not offer a complete explanation. It needs to keep consequences in view while refusing the cheap comfort of a label.
That balance is one reason literary conversation matters when a visual work arrives. Readers seeking a wider critical discussion can follow Tolkien and Middle-earth essays for essays, interviews and reflections on fantasy, authorship and the lasting reach of Middle-earth. Different forms ask different ethical questions. A film can place a dilemma before the eye; a book can return to its grammar, history and silences, allowing the reader to test how a verdict was built.
Justice without a final verdict
Justice in such a story cannot mean only the successful completion of the hunt. Aragorn’s renewed purpose, the Ring’s destruction and the party’s escape satisfy outcomes that a courtroom would call clear. Yet each outcome rests on acts whose moral shape is disputed. The final victory does not explain away every earlier cruelty, and Frodo’s continuing pain shows that success can leave a person divided between what was achieved and what it cost.
Samwise offers a sterner and more humane standard than either indulgence or revenge. He sees Gollum as a creature whose categories have failed him, yet he can still oppose him when the Ring draws near. Compassion in Middle-earth is not passive. It can require protection, resistance and even violence in defence of another person. The difficulty lies in choosing without pretending that the choice is painless.
The hunt for Gollum therefore leaves a double legacy. It exposes how easily a shared enemy becomes exempt from thought, and how an apparently peripheral figure can reveal the limits of the people who define themselves against him. A responsible judgement need not excuse Gollum, condemn him without context or split him into two neat creatures. It can recognise what was done, what was suffered and what remained possible, even when the Ring’s power has made possibility painfully small. The hunt may end; the demand for honest attention does not.